- Holly’s Helping Hand
- Teaching Cartoon: Principles
- Two Style Self-Reports
- Free Play Softball Slow Rolling Regression to the Mean
- Enlightenment, Now and Later
- Annals of Flight: Don’t Fly Drone Near Large Bird
- Penetrating Sensings – Coda.
- Penetrating Sensings II.
- Penetrating Sensings I.
- The Flux of Serendipity
- Teaching Cartoon: Look On the Bright Side
- Foiled By Inane Qualifications
- Free Play Rings the Bell Curve
- Teaching Cartoon: Something
- Signed Cosmos In an Ambiguous Multi-verse
“Why have we become like gods as technologists and like devils as moral beings, supermen in science and idiots in aesthetics – idiots above all in the Greek sense of absolutely isolated individuals, incapable of communicating among themselves or understanding one another?” Lewis Mumford
If you grow up, as we do, with a worship of the quantitative aspect and a minimal attention to the qualitative aspect, I believe you inevitably land yourself in the dilemmas of our civilization.
But I get back to the fact that the way we are going about things with this enormous emphasis upon the quantitative view and the minimal emphasis upon the patterned
view is, I believe, the easiest way of the descent into hell. The surest...
Gregory Bateson (1981)
- “The judgment of the intellect is, at best, only the half of truth, and must, if it be honest, also come to an understanding of its inadequacy. The dynamic principle of fantasy is play, a characteristic also of the child, and as such it appears inconsistent with the principle of serious work. But without this playing with fantasy no creative work has ever yet come to birth. The debt we owe to the play of imagination is incalculable. It is therefore short-sighted to treat fantasy, on account of its risky or unacceptable nature, as a thing of little worth.” The Psychology of Individuation, CG Jung
- Penetrating Sensings I.
- The Flux of Serendipity
- Boojums, Anti-finality, Art, and Learning
- Discovering Novel Approaches
- Cubes Upon Cubes
category cloudI Ching2dada2podcast3journalism & writing3speculations4Places4nature5zen5linguistics6nogutsnoglorystudios6cinema6blogging7friends7William James8art, artists8Libraries & Librarianship10visual story12poetry12integral13folk psychology14Karl Weick14my research19web 2.0+21cultural contradictions22cats23history26psychological anthropology26technology27serendipity27Cleveland28sociology32sufism36Gregory Bateson36education37philosophy38Religion42music46analytic(al) psychology46creative captures47play52self-knowledge55personal57Kenneth Warren59science64psychology65social psychology, organizational development71humor82visual experiments, my art94current events101experiential learning158adult learning234
Tagsa-ha! adult learning analytic psychology anthropology art biology buddhism charlatanry cognitive psychology consciousness critical culture critical thinking culture current events economics education experiential learning Freeplay Softball Gregory Bateson humor management music my casual art new paradigms organizational development phenomenology philosophy poetry politics pseudo-science psychology quotes religion resources Rumi science social psychology speculations sports sufism teaching cartoons teaching story transformative learning urbanology web media
- "It requires a very unusual mind to undertake the analysis of the obvious." - Alfred North Whitehead
- More email newsletters July 2, 2014
- new language annotation software June 25, 2014
- Software, Culture, and Political Economy in New Media Capitalism June 25, 2014
- ye olde net… June 25, 2014
- re the big data explosion June 10, 2014
Cleveland Heights, Ohio
- If, during the long course of ages and under varying conditions of life, organic beings vary at all in the several parts of their organization, and I think this cannot be disputed; if there be, owing to the high geometric powers of increase of each species, at some age, season or year, a severe struggle for life, and this certainly cannot be disputed; then, considering the infinite complexity of the relations of all organic beings to each other and to their conditions of existence, causing an infinite variety in structure, constitution, and habits, to be advantageous to them, I think it would be a most extraordinary fact if no variation ever had occurred useful to each being’s own welfare, in the same way as so many variations have occurred useful to man. But if variations useful to any organic being do occur, assuredly individuals thus characterized will have the best chance of being preserved in the struggle for life; and from the strong principle of inheritance they will tend to produce offspring similarly characterized. This principle of preservation, I have called, for the sake of brevity, Natural Selection. [Charles Darwin (1859) On the Origin of Species]
- “It is essential to such a government, that it be derived from the great body of the society, not from an inconsiderable proportion, or a favored class of it; otherwise a handful of tyrannical nobles, exercising their oppressions by a delegation of their powers, might aspire to the rank of republicans, and claim for their government the honorable title of republic.” James Madison
- All the property that is necessary to a Man, for the Conservation of the Individual and the Propagation of the Species, is his natural Right, which none can justly deprive him of: But all Property superfluous to such purposes is the Property of the Publick, who, by their Laws, have created it, and who may therefore by other laws dispose of it, whenever the Welfare of the Publick shall demand such Disposition. He that does not like civil Society on these Terms, let him retire and live among Savages. He can have no right to the benefits of Society, who will not pay his Club towards the Support of it. -Benjamin Franklin
Thinking Outside the Agora
- In Kazakhstan, the Soyuz TMA-18M Spacecraft Awaits Its Journey to the Stars September 1, 2015Here’s a low-angle look at the Russian Soyuz TMA-18M spacecraft, vertical on the launch pad in the Russian-leased Baikonur Cosmodrome in Kazakhstan. The rocket will blast off on Wednesday carrying astronauts from Russia, Kazakhstan, and Denmark to the International Space Station.Read more...
- Gizmodo Amazon Prime Is About to Get Worse | Jalopnik What The Hell Is Fiat Chrysler’s CEO Really Up August 31, 2015Gizmodo Amazon Prime Is About to Get Worse | Jalopnik What The Hell Is Fiat Chrysler’s CEO Really Up To? | Jezebel Why Isn’t Elisabeth Hasselbeck Classified As a Hate Group? | Kotaku What Was Your Worst Experience At A Video Game Store? | Kinja Popular Posts Read more...
- This is Exactly What New Horizons saw Zipping by Pluto August 31, 2015When the New Horizons spacecraft raced past Pluto this summer, it constantly snapped photographs both coming and going. This is exactly what it saw while zooming past the frozen dwarf planet. Whoa.Read more...
- Afternoon Hypnosis: Watch These Droplets Coalesce and Break at Terminal Velocity August 31, 2015It’s (relatively) easy to get water droplets to move at terminal velocity. They don’t even have to be moving relative to you. Just get air flowing upwards fast enough, and the water will hover, without increasing its speed up or down. Then throw more water drops at it, and see what happens.Read more...
- Untitled August 31, 2015Read more...
- In Kazakhstan, the Soyuz TMA-18M Spacecraft Awaits Its Journey to the Stars September 1, 2015
- Mold Super-Quick Edge Guards for Sharp Tools September 1, 2015
- Quilts Become Canvases When the Threadwork Is This Beautiful September 1, 2015
- 6 Crazy DIY String Instruments September 1, 2015
- Creepy Yet Beautiful: Jeweler Carves Pearls into Tiny Skulls September 1, 2015
- New Project: Create an Enclosure for a 6-Node Raspberry Pi Cluster September 1, 2015
- (M.A.K.) Halliday Center UK
- (OL) Can Scorpions Smoke
- (OL) Space for Learning
- 3rd-factory- (poetry)
- A Journey Round My Skull
- Abandoned Art
- Abigail McBirnie (PhD thesis)
- Acoustic Levitation
- Alan B Scrivener
- Alchemical Archives
- alexanne don
- alice o. howell
- Allison Hitt
- American Constitution Society
- American Libraries Magazine
- American Transcendentalism
- Andrew Gelman
- Andrew Gelman
- Andrew Taylor
- Anil Dash
- Anish Kapoor
- Anne Baring
- Annie Murphy Paul
- Annoyed Librarian
- Anthropoetics – UCLA
- Arnold Zwicky
- Arts & Letters Daily
- Arts, Philosophy, Politics, Science (group blog)
- Assoc. for Transpersonal Psychology
- Australian Institute of Parapsychological Research
- aviatime (aviation)
- Awati Kailash
- B. Alan Wallace
- Bad Astronomy
- Bad Science Blogs
- Baffler, The
- Barbara McAfee
- Barry Friedman
- Becoming Integral
- Bernard DeKoven (Deep Fun)
- Big Questions Online
- Big Questions Online
- bill callahan
- Bill Moyers
- Biosemiosis Blog
- Boing Boing
- brad delong
- brain and behavior
- Brain Facts
- Brainstorm (Chronicle of Higher Ed.)
- Brainstorm – Chronicle of Higher Education
- Brazen Careerist
- Brian Fitch
- Bronte Capital
- Browbeat @Slate
- bruce eisner
- Bruce Gerencser
- Brush Vox
- bryan alexander
- Bryan Jack
- Buckminster Fuller Institute
- Bud Harris
- C G Jung Institute – Chicago
- C.G. Jung Educational Center of Cleveland, Ohio
- C.G. Jung Foundation (NYC)
- C.G. Jung Institut Zurich
- C.G. Jung Institute of Los Angeles
- C.G. Jung Institute of San Francisco
- C.G. Jung Institute, Boston
- C.G.Jung Page
- Cabinet Magazine (Culture)
- Cara Finnegan
- Carl Jung Depth Psychology
- Carl Jung.net
- Cassandra Does Tokyo
- Catholic Sensibility
- certain doubts
- Certain Doubts
- charles cameron
- charles daney
- Charles Dominey
- Charles S. Pierce
- Chris Cléirigh Thoughts That X My mind
- chris corrigan
- Chris Dalton
- Chris Hallquist
- Chris Hoff
- Christopher G. Weaver
- Christopher Irion
- CJ Shivers
- Cleveland Consulting Group
- cognitive biases
- Collective Wisdom Institute
- Columbia Journalism Review
- comics curmudgeon
- Conservative Outlooks
- Constructivist Foundations (Journal)
- Contextual Criticsm
- Contraction & Convergence: Climate Change Truth & Reconciliation
- Contrary Librarian
- Corey Robin
- Corporation for Positive Change
- cosma rohilla shalizi
- Creative Applications Networks
- Creative Blog
- crispin sartwell
- Critical Thinking
- Critiques of ELT at reviewing.co.uk
- Crystal Links
- Culture Wars – UK
- Daily Cat
- daniel gustav anderson
- Daring Fireball
- david & alice kolb
- david brin
- david chalmers
- David Cooperrider
- David Cooperrider & Chris Johnston
- Dean Raddin
- Deborah Bird Rose
- deborah mattingly conner
- Depth Psychology Alliance
- Derek Melser
- Derek Thompson (Atlantic)
- Details On Request (collective)
- deterritorial investigations unit
- Developmental Observer
- Diane Ravitch
- dienekes anthropology blog
- Dierdre McCloskey
- Digital Buzz Blog
- Doc Searles
- Don't Privatise Libraries
- Doug Ashford
- Doug Berch
- Doug Ireland (defunct)
- Douglas Lockhart
- Dr. Cornel West
- Dr. Jeff Howlin
- Dr. Jon Mills
- Dr. Michael Sudduth
- Dr. Peter Milhado
- Dr. Samuel James DeVries
- Dr.WooHoo – generative Art
- duane smith
- Earliest Christianity
- Earthscore (Paul Ryan)
- Echo Partners Blog
- ed morrison
- Edward Feser
- edward vielmetti
- Elizabeth Stoker Bruenig
- Embodiment.org (UK)
- Encyclopaedia of Educational Theory & Philosophy
- Enlightened Spirituality
- Epicurean Dealmaker
- eric schwitzgebel
- Esoteric Online
- ethan zuckerman
- EU Cognition.Org
- Evan Thompson
- Evangellically Atheist
- eve neuhaus
- Eve Neuhaus Blog
- evelyn rodriguez
- Everything Means Something
- Evolutionary Psychology Journal
- Evolving Deep Forms
- EvoS Consortium Blog
- Excess of Democracy
- Exile On moan Street
- Expanding Your World
- Exploring Our Matrix at Patheos
- Eye on the Institute For Creation Research
- Ezequiel Di Paolo
- Ezequiel di Paolo (blog)
- FastCo. Design
- Feral Librarian
- Film School Rejects
- fiona jordan
- First Things
- Flow Power
- FOundation for Economic Education
- Frank Rich
- Fredrik DeBoer
- Free Buddhist Audio
- Free Thought Blogs
- Free Thought Dispatches
- Freire Project
- Friendly Atheist
- Fucking Good Art
- future now
- Future Primitive.org
- Gaby Dunn
- gardner campbell
- garrett p vreeland
- Gary Farber
- Gary Greenburg
- Gary Weiss
- Generative Art – Very Interactive People (archive)
- Generator X
- Geoff Baker
- george por
- George Veletsianos
- gerald swatez
- Giulia Forsyth
- Glenn Perry
- God Discussion
- God Math, Bad Math
- Gordy Slack
- Gray Crawford
- Greg Mitchell
- Group: Network Weaver
- h+ Magazine
- Haikus and Pics
- Harlan Ellison
- Harlene Anderson
- Heide Kolb (archive)
- Henry A. Giroux
- Henry Mintzberg
- heward wilkinson
- Hippo Reads
- Holographic Archetypes
- Hubaisms (religion)
- Humour Only
- Ian Glendinning's Psybertron
- Ian Welsh
- if charlie parker was a gunslinger…
- If You Find the Earth Boring
- Immanuel Wallerstein
- in the library with a lead pipe
- Incidental Economist
- Infoism – Libraries
- Inky Fool (Mark Forsythe)
- Inner Explorations
- Inspiration Grid
- Institute for Experiential Learning
- Institute for Polarity and Paradox
- Institute for Southern Studies
- Int'l Bateson Institute
- Int'l Skeptics Forum
- Integral leadership Review
- Integral Post-Metaphysics
- International Film Studies
- Internet Tendency
- Iona Miller
- Islamophobia Today
- J Siry
- JAC Journal of Rhetoric, Culture & Politics
- jack ricchuito
- james howard kuntsler
- James Randi, debunker
- jane knight
- jane mcgonigal
- Janet Kwasniak
- Jason E Smith
- Jay Porter
- Jayson Gaddis
- Jean Raffa
- Jeff Bloom
- Jeff Matthews
- Jesper Hoffmeyer
- jesus general
- Jill Miller Zimon
- jim hightower
- jim&miriam@executive edge
- John C. Woodcock
- john hagel
- john hawks
- john morehead
- John Naughton
- Jon F Wilkins
- Jonathan Chait
- Jonathan Hockey
- jonathan mayhew
- Journal of Play
- Jung 2.0
- Jung Currents
- Jung Currents
- Jung Poland
- Jung Society of Washington
- Jungian Center Org
- Jungian Society for Scholarly Studies
- Kalevi Kull
- Karel Donk
- Kate Bornstein
- kate kuper
- Kate Sharpley Library
- Kay Peterson – Learning Partners Group
- Ken Wilber
- Ken's Blog
- Kenneth J. Gergen
- Kernel Mag
- kevin kelly
- Killing Mother
- KK Cool Tools
- Laetus In Praesens
- Lapham's Quarterly
- Lark news
- Laura Duhan Kaplan (Sophiastreet)
- Laura Kerr
- Law and Life
- Leaky Grammar
- Learning Stewards
- Leonardo Solaas
- leslie yerkes
- Lewis Lapham (podcasts)
- Liberator Magazine
- Librarian Shipwreck
- Librarians in the Wild
- Library As Incubator
- Library Juice Press
- limited inc
- Lin Batsheva
- lisa haneberg
- Lisa Hirsch
- Lisa Houck
- Livia Blackburne
- Living Anthropologically
- ljubljana digital media lab
- M.J. Horne
- Maajid Nawaz
- mad kane
- Magazine Good Is
- Mai P. Trinh
- Mai P. Trinh
- Mail&Guardian (ZA)
- marc lefkowitz
- Marco Arment
- Maria Konikkova
- Maria Popova's Brain Pickings
- Mark Federman
- mark oehlert
- mark sarvas
- Mark Thoma
- Martin Packer
- Mary Flanagan
- Mary Flanagan Grand Text Auto
- MAry Parker Follett Network
- massimo pigliucci
- MDPI Open Access Journals
- Meta-Integral Institute
- michael dorf
- Michael Hudson
- Michael Mayer
- michael stephens
- Mighty Creative Deals
- mike dickman
- Mike Lehr
- Mitchell Freedman
- Mock Paper Scissors
- Morgan Guyton
- MS social media collective
- Mythic Jounreys
- N.A. Community for Cultural Ecology
- naked capitalism
- Nancy Baym
- Nancy Dixon
- NAncy Freeman
- Nancy White (Full Circle)
- Nassim N. Taleb
- Nat'l Creativity Network
- Nature Inquiries
- Nature World Report
- neurophenomenology blog
- NeuroQuantology (Journal)
- New Deal 2.0
- New Horizons For Learning
- New Left Review
- New York Association for Analytical Psychology
- News at Science Magazine
- NLP Wiki
- No More Mister Nice Blog
- Noel G. Charlton
- Occupy at Guardian UK
- Open Access Journals
- Open Secrets
- Open Semiotics
- Organizational Capacity Building
- Otis Funkmeyer
- Otto Scharmer
- Pacific Free Press
- Pacific Standard Magazine
- Paradox (literature) Wikipedia
- pat kane-play ethic
- Path of Soul
- Paul Krugman
- Paulo Coelho
- Peter Guyer
- peter levine
- peter wall
- Phenomenology Blog
- philosophical blogs-portal
- Philosophy of Brains
- Philosophy of Information & Communication Blog
- philosophy talk
- Pinch Journal
- Polarity Partnerships
- Political notebook
- Political Wire
- Portal to the Universe
- Preservation Institute
- Press Think (Jay Rosen)
- Principia Cybernetica
- Progressive Librarians Guild
- Progressive Pulse (NC)
- Public Libraries News
- Radical Librarians Collective (UK)
- Ralph Stacey
- ramesh jain
- Ran Prieur
- Ratical: Nature of Thought
- Reality Chex
- Recollecting Philosophy
- Red bubble
- Regina Loiko
- Religion Dispatches
- Rethinking Complexity
- Rethinking Complexity (Saybrook)
- Richard Beck
- richard chappell
- Richard Jung
- Rightwing Watch
- Robert David Steele
- robert g. longpre
- Robert J Waldman
- Robert's Stochastic Thoughts
- Roger Brooke, PhD
- rose f. holt
- Rose+Croix Journal
- Rupert Sheldrake
- s roden
- Sabrina Ratte
- Sachiko McLean
- Sadly, No
- Sandra Huggen
- sarah houghton-jan
- Sarah Perry
- sasha frere-jones
- Scholar's Strategy Network
- scholars and rogues
- Science & Sciencibility
- Scientia Salon
- sean jacobs
- Seed Magazine
- Seed Magazine
- Seeker After Truth
- Senser, Sensing
- Sensuous Curmudgeon
- SerenA: chance and ideas
- Serendip @Bryn Mawr
- Seth Godin
- Seth Roberts
- Seth Steinzor, Poet
- SFL (linguistics)
- Shams-i-bala and The Historical Shambhala Kingdom
- Sign Systems Studies
- Skeptical Inquirer
- Sketches of Topology
- Slate Star Codex
- Smashing Magazine (web design)
- Snuggle Factory
- Social Justice Solutions
- Society for Scientific Exploration (reviews)
- Sociocultural Theory in Anthropology
- Sociological Cinema (portal)
- St Ottilien
- Stacy McGaugh
- Stanislav Grof
- Stephanie Pope
- stephen abrams
- stephen downes
- Stephen Downs
- Stephen Ellis
- steve dahlberg
- Steve Farmer
- strange maps
- Strategies of the Artificial
- Streams & Mirrors
- Subverting Subverting the Genre
- Subverting Subverting the Genre
- Subverting the Genre
- Susan Blackmore
- Suzana Vaz
- Symbolic-Interaction Journal
- TAlking Philosophy
- Tallahassee Center for Jungian Studies
- Techgnosis (Erik Davis)
- Teleodynamics (2013)
- Ten Zen Questions – Susan Blackmore
- Territories of the Alive (2012)
- terry fund
- terry teachout
- The Analytical Psychology Center of Western NY
- The Analytical Psychology Society of Western NY
- The Awl
- The Berkeley Blog
- The Boston Review
- the bounds of cognition (defunct)
- The Bounds of Cognition (defunct)
- The Brains Blog
- The Browser
- The Chive
- The City Journal
- The Creator's Project
- The Curious Wave Function
- The Current Moment
- The Cybernetics Society (UK)
- the defeatists
- The Economic Way of Thinking
- The European Magazine
- The Good Men Project
- The Hedgehog Review (IASC)
- The Humanist
- The Information Philosopher
- The Int'l Assoc. For Jungian Studies
- The League of Ordinary Gentlemen
- The Monist Magazine
- The Monkey Cage
- The Monkey Cage
- The Monkey Cage
- The MOON Magazine
- The New Atlantis
- The Orthosphere
- The Philosopher's Magazine
- The Philosophy Magazine
- The Poor Man
- The Root
- the thought occurs
- the thought occurs
- The Twenty-first Floor
- The Ubiquitous Librarian
- The UNZ Review
- The Urban Flux
- the view from hell (Sarah Perry)
- Thinking Outside the Agora
- Thinking Outside the Agora
- This Modern World
- thivai abhor
- thomas p m barnett
- thoughts arguments rants
- Thoughts From Kansas
- Thoughts In a Haystack
- Thoughts That Cross My Mind
- Three-Toed Sloth
- Tibor R Machan
- Tikvah Company of Artists
- Timothy Quinlan
- Tom Slee
- ton zijlstra
- Transhuman Traditionalism
- Trust Me, I'm a Librarian
- Tucker Stilley
- Two Friars and a Fool
- Type In Depth
- Typology Central
- U. Boeschenstein
- Understanding Society
- Understanding War
- United With Loving
- urs boeschenstein
- Vicki Hill
- vincent horn
- virginia postrel
- Voegelin View
- volh conspiracy
- walter logeman
- Walter Logeman – ART
- walter logeman in this moment
- War Is Boring
- War On the Rocks
- We Are the 99%
- White Noise of Everyday Life
- Why i Am Catholic
- Wi=m James Studies.org
- Wild River Review
- William Hogeland
- william tozier
- william vallicella
- Woe & Joy
- World Science U
- yale research guides-by-subject
- yvonne divita
- Zara Picken-Hovering Cat
- Zero Anthropology
- Zinn Project
Category Archives: visual experiments, my art
Over the past few years I have not combined a vertical with a ‘flipped’ horizontal symmetry so as to synthesize the above stack.
Presumably, there is a transcendent function hidden in my (a) intention, or, (2) unconscious urge, because it goes from the two via the processual three to the whole four.
Two, plus two, next four.
odis tamquam fures et homicidas, tamquam specula celesti fulgore micantia mirare cogeris et amare.46
(you hate them as robbers and murderers; you love and worship them as mirrors reflecting a celestial light)
dialog of Ficino
My artistic sensibility admits as much, so, not surprisingly, the visual result is completed by the viewer, and, as well, the dialectical stasis captured in the moment of the viewer’s experience is also ‘half’ in the sensibility of the viewer. I term this: diastasis. The basic formulation could be enumerated, one, two, three, four; so this is most simply: creation, field, experience, engagement. The hidden bridge in the (social) cybernetic sense is the viewer’s abduction, which is the means for the viewer ‘reason-experiencing’ to the best explanation of their experience of the forms hidden in plain sight.
As the creator, I do not code those abductions into the visual field (piece.) Rather, their animation is contingent on the four-fold, as is this ‘adding up’ to: mirrors reflecting a celestial light.
This is, from certain perspectives, a very serious business!
Engagement (transcendent function)
(I would use different terms than Adorno, yet it is self-evident to me that the viewer completes the engaging experience with her own cultural conditioning. Because my aesthetic is intentionally underdetermined as a matter of the constitutive generativity underlying both creative process and artistic product, my aesthetic also greatly underdetermines the programmatic encoding. I like to think this lack of masterful coding sets the piece free from being only a simple message.)
Loss of a person, of a close frriend or of a family member, presents a challenging process which won’t let go as it impels me through its requisite travail.
At the same time, the outward conventions of concern and courtesy basically allow for a restoration of human contact in the collective terms of concern and courtesy, and, sure, in the terms of grief and mourning.
These expressions are helpful, even as the expressed kindnesses and concerns seem to me to reach around the really bare, and profoundly forward-pitched facts. Of course, I would do the same thing, in approaching somebody’s loss, in approaching a ‘death in the family.’ Except, at the same time, I would be always holding back my usual, or my habitual, curiosity.
I would reign in my researcher’s soul.
What is actually going on?
I previously mentioned, or I think I did so, that in the weeks between meeting Ken for the first time and our second meeting, he reported to me that he had read my entire web site and blog. At the time he made this report, I didn’t know really what kind of ‘reader’ was Ken. Still, I was very impressed because he had begun what we came to call, ‘the forensics;’ and I had begun the same process. Furthermore, apparently, we shared this similarity, we both knew more data is better than both a little data, and, the thin positive capability through which a little data and bad guesswork are joined together.
Gone! Okay, what is actually going on with you Stephen? This is the question that can be addressed to me.
I do bring in, and try to warmly receive, the heartfelt substitutions for this non-obvious question. Oh, it was not a non-obvious question to Ken. When my mother passed away in early 2012, he asked me,
“What is going on?”
And, he kept asking. I’ll miss his researcher’s tenacity! If somebody doesn’t ask me this question, he or she is missing the boat. I’m not missing it, I’m in it.
I have put much of the actual goings on ‘with me’ in the aftermath of my loss, ‘out there,’ here, on my blog. (This blog is iteration number three, begun five months after meeting Ken in the fall of 2004.)
2. the LOVE BASIS
3. COMBINATORIAL questing
4. active DECONSTRUCTION
5. the ANIMA PROBLEM
6. interlude: what you don’t know, give into
7. interlude: process and reality
8. NEGATIVE CAPABILITY, Irony
Ken would have appreciated why the number of posts is eight. Hey, I’m throwing out clues here!
He and I agreed on a great great deal, although as I have tried to make clear, Ken was entangled by his enthusiasms, whereas I am mostly afraid of my own; (so, I trained myself to be a fallibilist.)
Also, I feel as if I need to be careful. But, it isn’t also true that anybody should feel he or she is to be a second fiddle. Heck, go for it. Life is unpredictable. And, you’re unlikely to figure out in advance when your last breath is steaming down the tracks.
Close relations are my second highest value–and are so for reasons I’m able to express. Ask me. Go for it.
Ken and I spent a lot of time deconstructing what to us–to maybe only us–was the single most bloody problem in the ‘scape of modernity, (that:) the fundamental problem is relational incapacity, not deficits in rationality or critical thinking.
Note, the structure goes from Shock to Negative Capability. It goes from oh no, shit! to soul!
Yes, it was terrific and quite medicinal, perhaps even karmically medicinal, to feel really extremely thoroughly known by Ken, yet, I’ve mapped out the foundation to be: going from the LOVE BASIS to the COMBINATORIAL. Ken and I were sensemakers, this is what we did over many thousands of hours. Why?
What is actually going on?
Why? …such a good question. We never discussed explicitly dialogical recognition (Charles Taylor,) yet when we together took up the cause of the noetic public library we sorted out a deep congruence about the micro problems come to coalesce around the macro problems of–within the pragmatics of praxis in a library–reification, instrumentalism, objectification, dehumanization, and, well, how it is, apparently, easy to rip the fucking heart of a library out of its cavity, and place in this cavity a bunch of 3D printers.
Similarly, most societal problems at the scale of the kind of civics citizens actually can effectively practice, are initiated in the first order by the atrophy of the human ability to actively know one other. Ken and I understood our diagnosis would deconstruct this order of knowing. Then, for the sake of reanimating the civic heart and civic capacity for making sense, we worked over how in a city or in a library how citizens might collaborate on a new, deeper (3rd) order of interpersonal and intrapersonal knowing cum relationship.
In the light of the ideal of authenticity, it would seem that having merely instrumental relationships is to act in a self-stultifying way. The notion that one can pursue one’s fulfilment in this way seems illusory, in somewhat the same way as the idea that one can choose oneself without recognizing a horizon of significance beyond choice. Authenticity a picture of what a better or higher mode of life would be, where better and higher are defined not in terms of what we happen to desire or need, but offer a standard of what we ought to desire. (Charles Taylor)
Ken and I spent zero time slapping each other on the back when we discovered, for example, we both were familiar with Paolo Freire. It was all matter-of-fact because it is who you are, not what you know, and, so, study for the love of the quest. Train first! Deploy, drill down, together stick our hands in the muck.
What is actually going on?
When we turned this around, our critical chops came to meld Ken’s learned Saturnian thrust with my edge-seeking Promethean swing. Ken possessed this aspect, one that was like the boy with a hammer, the boy who would swing his hammer at everything; and, I, an actual complexed puer, possessed a kind of penetrating Apollonian cynicism, and, also I, a Batesonian, was able to stand back a bit. (Well, I didn’t want to get accidentally rapped by the hammer.) Yet, when we got going. . .
we’d cover stuff very very quickly. ‘Marx was not even a horrible psychologist, yet Russell was on the money in noting Marx was a Christian heretic.’ ‘Jung only had an inkling that he had birthed a psychology and its daughters from his lapsed Lutheran brow, and that his psychology’s wider applications were somewhat covertly undermined by this creation story.’ ‘There are short paragraphs in the Tibetan Canon, or the best haiku, which could right now replace and improve every word Ken Wilber has ever scribbled.’
‘cover’ doesn’t mean getting it correct.
Ken, by the way, fulfilled the demands of authentic relationship with many many people. He and I were in a synergistic profoundly complementary relationship, and spent no time gratuitously or otherwise aggrandizing how great was our relationship, except we did once briefly consider some of the contingencies and fortuities and errors which had to slowly collapse, like a holy wave function organizing its effective reality, or ‘reality,’ and do so over two lifetimes, all for the sake of being able to efficiently and cleanly deploy together the practical and/or explosive tools our dialectical instigations, spontaneous poetics, and channeled intuitions, came to evoke and muster.
Did it help our effort that we happened to have both traveled through some of the same ideational and metaphysical lands? See: Interlude #3 tomorrow.
Nevertheless, our learned congruency was like a picture pasted to the jig pieces of a puzzle. With time, and it still is going to take time no matter what, two people working together can piece the puzzle together without having to refer to the ‘parted’ picture on the surface of each piece.
What Ken and I disagreed about: particular ramifications. For example, the ramifications implicitly of this perspective:
Ken, you should just give up trying to trick me.
Ken respected where I could not go. I had occasion to remind him earlier this year that “such respect then leads irrevocably to my Promethean liberation of Astrology and Psycho-astrology,” (and how I came to amputate various fixities from their thin causal relations.)
I had planned to take him (this summer) through The Reduced Bateson Set. (Oh well.) We had begun to recast some of the developmental fixations in learning theorizing and in specific theories, like the theory of my friend, David Kolb. Obviously, to where the action learning of our entwined dialectical picking and drumming would have led to, is about as unknowable as an unknown could be.
I had submitted a Cube-O-Probe, as a visual poem, to House Organ. Ken rarely specified the ways in which our workplay was influencing his numerous other projects. But, he was a boy with a hammer! He took his set #2 of Cubes and fearlessly interpreted their message on behalf of astrologers, poets, and nieces.
Another lesser, and vital congruency, brought forth one of the essential fundamentals able to support our mindful and creative travels: as it happens, an exquisitely sensitive humane esotericist breaks bread with a mercurial edge-seeking flatlander because the whole cause of inverting assumptions and sometimes having to mulch them is shared and equally served by two radically different sensibilities–except for, as Rumi noted, our “fleshy hearts.”
We traveled and never went anywhere. We made a road trip to the Target in North Olmsted for the sake of a veteran who had just rented a crib in Lakewood but didn’t have a bed.
We made a bunch of trips to Wadsworth in support of our fellow traveler, Daniel and his public library.
“Ken, would you please try to keep at least one hand on the wheel?”
When I had reason to remind Ken that I am, by disposition, a “deep ironicist,” he told me this assertion perplexed him. I told him,
“Come on Ken, you’re the one who titled me, Dr. Puck.”
Then, I explained to him what imperatives are driven by chops, negative capability, good/bad fortune, large collections of devices and heuristics, multitudes of perspectives, plus the ability to rappel down to the “meta,” and, I went on,
“then there are also all those just-in-time intuitions blowing into your scheme like neutrinos stream through the material world, except you and me grab at ’em and we bring the intuition back alive, from wherever was its ‘wild,’ and you stick ’em to your wall, They always seem to stick.”
“Yeah, Ken, your sort of an ironicist too.”
Forgive & let go
open the head
free the heart
be wary of vengeance
a life for a death
if you can’t
see anyone entire
there’s no one
not even you
death is a giving up
risen as having gone
the theatre of art
the spirit of fact
what you don’t know
what the mind thinks
(Vincent Ferrini, The Pleroma, 2008)
Kenneth Warren wrote the Introduction.
A young man had finished his schooling and thus was hanging around the house.
His mother told him, “It is exactly the right moment to figure out what you are going to do with your life.”
The young man nodded his head. He also decided to get out of the house and spend more time in the village and observe what was going on every day there–because he hoped he would discover a clue about what he was to do.
For most of the next month he did exactly this. Over those weeks he found himself gravitating to a healer, a specialist in the ills of the back and spine. He observed people barely able to make it through the front door because their pain was so bad. He observed people returning after their treatment too. He figured these were follow up visits. These people were apparently free of back pain.
One day he announced to his mother,
“I’m going to ask the good back doctor, Dr. Fine, if he will take me on as an apprentice.”
His mother turned to him and nodded.
The young man felt good about his decision. One morning he knocked on the door moments after he had observed Dr. Fine arrive for the day’s consultations and treatments. He asked the doctor if he might need an apprentice. The doctor thought for a long moment and replied:
“Yes, you can join me as a student. All you’ll be required to do is watch closely, and, hold all your questions until I come to feel you have spent enough time watching.”
The young man thought to himself, ‘Simple enough,’ and nodded, and told Dr. Fine,
“Thank you very much!”
Over the next several months, the young man arrived everyday at the same time, put on a white lab coat, and, dutifully watched Dr. Fine work with, and on, his patients. As his time being watchful grew, the young man’s list of questions began to shrink.
Then one day, a middle-aged gentlemen somehow dragged himself into the examination room in a terrible state and in pain so great it was hard to watch. But Dr. Fine took a history, had the man lie down and rest, and then sent him home after asking him to make an appointment for a week later.
The young man was surprised by this case. All the previous worst cases looked the same: Dr. Fine would take a history, do an examination, have the patient lie down and rest for an hour, and then he would give the patient a quarter of a pomegranate. He would direct the patient to eat a tenth of the pomegranate each morning. Finally he would schedule a follow up to take place three weeks after the ten day course.
The young man had been Dr. Fine’s watchful apprentice long enough to see how wonderfully effective the pomegranate cure was for the persons stricken with the most terrible back afflictions.
This case was different. At Dr. Fine’s request, this same patient came back three times, and, each time he was sent away without the curative pomegranate. Finally, on the fourth visit, Dr. Fine gave the man the usual course of pomegranate.
A month later this same patient strode through the door for his follow-up appointment. He declared himself ‘a new man,’ and Dr. Fine nodded his affirmation.
The young man bit his tongue. Still, when Dr. Fine closed up for the day, as both stood on the small front porch, the young man turned to Dr. Fine and put to the good doctor his very first question,
“I have to ask this question, for I am disturbed to observe you give your worst cases the pomegranate medicine on their first visit, yet this patient today was made to wait a month. Why?”
The doctor put his hand on the young man’s shoulder,
“You see, every case is actually different, and is unique in its own way. The patient today presented a very difficult case and, likewise, the treatment recognized this, for where many unique cases are resolved by the pomegranate and healing regimen, in this man’s case, his difficulties could only be resolved by time and pomegranates.“
With this, Dr. Fine, nodded, turned in the direction of walk home, and departed for the day.
(Adapted from a cassette recording of a presentation of Idries Shah.)
There was a point last month when I ran out of cell phone minutes for the first time ever. It came at a critical juncture. At the time I was coordinating printing of my pieces by Stan Bowman in Ithaca and trying to identify how the pieces were to finished by their being mounted on some substrate. Plus, I was trying to get them to the auctioneer in a timely manner. All of this was accompanied by my trying to–over the phone–learn and unlearn and take into account and discount, all the information I was obtaining, while seeking to inform myself about how/why to make the several final decisions, while, at the same time, predicting how the final production processes will cough up two finished pieces.
Sometime before, in early March, Kate of Gray’s, kindly provided the critical clue, yet, it took me a month to integrate it. She told me. “At the end of the day, it’s up to the artist to figure out what it is that makes for a completed piece.”
I ended up getting this, and, I made the final decisions. I did the successful experiment of having the pieces reprinted directly on aluminum. I kept the faces open, glassless, and, organic. My process wandered in a kind of wilderness for a month, but I got to the end of the day. The results are fantastic.
Dream, actually a solid anima dream, from January 2014:
People are walking through a gallery of art.
I’m off to the side watching the people stop and look at the art pieces.
To myself I muse, ‘I’m the only one here who knows who is the artist.’
(The pieces are my own.)
Soon enough a very old lady is helped along by a young woman in a maid’s outfit.
They stop at the picture I’m standing to the side of. The young girl lets go of the old lady and steps close to the picture.
After a while, the girl says out loud, “Oh, I like this one very much.”
The old lady responds in a grumpy, raspy voice, “Then, he should sell it.”
I asked the probe with Ken as the witness, “What should I investigate to acclimate myself to the public for art,” and, presumably to the segment possibly interested in my art. As always, the Probe tells no lies. Its suggests looking deeper into the mercurial shadow quadrant where the indication is that (my) listening and receiving feedback will be crucial. Crones Says is synchronistic verification and it also echoes my late mother’s aperçu from ten years ago, “I have figured out you have the soul of an artist!”
The last two months have been, for me, completely different from my “norm.” I’ve had to steward two pieces through printing and media finishing processes, and, in the latter stage, I encountered several dramatic bumps in the road. I learned a lot, and I’ve learned to trust my somewhat innocent judgments about technical matters, even as I negotiate the first stretch of a big learning curve.
The biggest difference in my daily program has been how much time I have devoted, and devoured, in going back into the archives of unfinished pieces and old experiments, and reanimating a string of pieces that I set aside because I didn’t want to proof them at their optimal display dimensions. See the earlier post on this.
My normal, light, scattered days, usually spent pursuing my feeling for experiences–be it studying various subjects, or contemplating or investigating or making music or doing visual experiments, or talking up friends, colleagues, projects, or designing experiential tools–has been set to the side as I’ve thrown myself into what I can call the maiden dream.
Crone Say, indeed!
(The above picture is my own assembly; and it is not a picture of an actual installation. It aims to show the scale of the two pieces.)
Two of my procedural pieces were invited to, and now are placed, in the May 6 Auction of Modern and Contemporary Art, presented by Gray’s Auctioneers, Cleveland’s principal international auction house. The auction preview and virtual bidding phase began April 6.
Come to the Mardi Gras (40w x 58h”) -2014- Lot 103
Mythic Figure (32w x 48h”) -2013- Lot 104
Among several distinctive modal differences of the digital realm, this difference between the scale of the original computer file and workspace and the final formatted production piece presents challenges. My current pieces are, with respect to this, built to be large, with a minimum of 36-44 inches on the shorter side. The original printable proof in its initial digital stage, prior to dimensional enlargement, is sized to the longer side at 11 to 19 inches.
Although my display and proofing environment is calibrated to unity, the display size is maxed out at roughly one foot on the longest possible side on the dispaly (screen.) This means I’ve had to develop the ability to translate the feel of this screen into a vision of the final physical piece. In working to finalize large pieces, this means I am working on images that are not ever greater than 20% of the size of the finished, large piece.
My recent work is all about the grabbing the viewer and bringing the viewer into the image. I have lots of ways of describing this objective, but the simplest appeal my work makes is concerned with the truth of the viewer’s imaginative experience of the piece rather concerned with the transmission of an aesthetic or programmatic value.
I’ve been working diligently and tenaciously on pieces with this experiential goal in mind, and, to support it, I’m making the pieces really large, large enough to take over a wall, and, to take people on a trip of their own devising.
Sun Ra In Heaven (2015) 44 x 66″
Today, I grabbed by DSLR and took some photos of the early spring ground at locations where ‘complexity’ of the certain sort my symmetry-based photographic art is founded upon could be found and captured. The above image is a quickee.
I updated my Artist’s Statement at My Naive Art online gallery site.
Here it is, although I hope you’ll follow the link and check out my gallery.
Creating visual pieces is a musical process. My guiding intentions are to learn by doing experiments, discover unique territories by implicating factors of serendipity and novelty, and, enjoy my adventurous creative process.
My art’s goal is to first grip the viewer, and next draw he or she into exploration and into surprising experience. This comes to a fine confrontation between apprehensive sensibility and artwork in my recent symmetry pieces. These have been described as approximating the effect of a Rorsach pattern. Yes!
Pareidolia is the psychological phenomenon where people see recognizable shapes in clouds, rock formations, or otherwise unrelated objects or data.
It is by my artistic intention that I aim to evoke a moment of psychological discovery to be waged in the representational folds of the symmetry pieces. So it is: I hope for the viewer to inhabit an evocative experience of Pareidolia.
Echoing both my research interest in serendipity in adult development and my musical aesthetic as an improvising composer, the raw exploration involved in seeking out a compelling artistic production is deeply woven betwixt intentional technique and generative/stochastic procedures. The aim is to capture an opportunity for myself and viewers of pure experience.
As pianist Paul Bley aptly said of jazz, ‘it is composing in real time.’ In my visual realm, I compose in serendipitous time.
Stephen, March 2015
Where In the World? Workshop Series. Deploying Google Earth as a source of overhead urban images of sufficient complexity and character to further work via manipulative mirroring routines; and, also using Photoshop actions to further manipulate the look.
These three images, then, represent different experiments. My perspective is similar to that of the great jazz bassist Charles Mingus, who characterized his musical explorations as being “incomplete and unending workshops in sound and organization.”
These three experiments reflect screen captures of overhead views of a particular city that is known to me and would be a puzzle to resolve, for the viewer.
Symmetry experiments at symmetry-hypothesis@tumblr
Going Down – 14×11″, from a photograph, 2015, Stephen Calhoun – my symmetry experiments on tumblr
The studio on the third floor of our century home is rarely the warmest location in the house, but, whereas the first floor had settled in at 56–as our gas furnace just couldn’t keep up–the studio in the attic was at 66 degrees!
I worked on some music, then worked on a remix of the famous Nile mosaic.
Egyptian Mandala Version #1 (2015, S.Calhoun) remix of the Nile Mosaic
My series of experiments visually remixing Peter Brueghel the Elder by using symmetry manipulations led me to my next subject, Hieronymus Bosch.
Here are several keepers
Very little is known about Bosch, which somehow seems fitting since his work is so enigmatic. We know that he adopted the name of the Dutch town of s’Hertogenbosch (near Antwerp) as his own, that he belonged to an ultra-orthodox religious community called the Brotherhood of Mary, and that in his own day he was famous. Many of his paintings are devotional, and there are several on the theme of the Passion. He is specially famous for his fantastic, demon-filled works. (src)
Hieronymus Bosch, the Trendiest Apocalyptic Medieval Painter of 2014
The Garden of Earthly Delights is now on leggings, in children’s books, and getting name-checked by cool bands. Why?
The Pen – 12×12″ – from a photograph – S.Calhoun
Although it is evidently visible yet there is no one there who sees it. Amazing!
Even though it exists in everyone everywhere yet it has gone unrecognized. Amazing!
Nevertheless, you hope to obtain some other fruit than this elsewhere. Amazing!
Even though it exists within yourself and nowhere else yet you seek for it elsewhere. Amazing!
Brueghel: The Alchemist
This piece is part of a large series that will likely be presented in a short film. The film is intended to show the interplay of manipulations and recursions involved in generating different pieces.
I dedicate this new series to Ms. Uidhi. (I may be one of a handful of artists, or pseudo-artists, focusing on creative luckiness in the context of a post-academic post-scholarly focus on the situation of serendipity in adult development. This could include meandering into philosophical swamps.
IP LAF Forum: Christy Mag Uidhi on Artistic Serendipity vs. Artistic Luck, 25 Sept
INSTITUTE OF PHILOSOPHY
Thurs 25 September 2014, 4.00pm
IP London Aesthetics Forum: Room G34, Senate House, WC1
Artistic Serendipity vs. Artistic Luck
Christy Mag Uidhi (Houston)
Supported by the British Society of Aesthetics
It is standardly thought that artworks may gain and lose art-relevant properties over time (and thereby may also admit of similar gains and losses in artistic value). From this it follows that insofar as such gains and losses may be well outside the control of the artist, we ought to expect any minimally adequate theory of art and its value as such to come with (or at least be amenable to) some minimal notion of artistic luck and artistic achievement (such that ascriptions of the one undermine ascriptions of the other). In this talk, I’ll sketch what I take to be uncontroversial minimal accounts of both artistic luck and artistic achievement. From these I show it to follow that if artworks must be products of intentional action, then there can be no such thing as artistic luck (either descriptively or evaluatively). I claim the only formative role luck might play in our understanding of art and its value as such is to provide the means by which we may productively carve out an informative sub-class of artistic achievement: specifically that of artistic serendipity.
[My bold.] Intention, serendipity. Intentional serendipity is pseudo-serendipity. It is a kind of search routine. I don’t subscribe to the idea that intentionality is properly monolithic or exclusionary. But, I concede that psychologizing the artist’s creative process may take my own considerations and sensemaking out of and away from a proper philosophy of aesthetics.
Nor do I know what Ms. Mag Uidhi has in mind to flesh out the intriguing precis.
For my own part, there is so much in my creative process that permits creative intention-up-to-the-point of pulling the curtains away, and, thus includes less discrete combinations of intention and, fundamentally, hope about the unknown!
Hell, S.Calhoun (2014) symmetry experiment
Heaven and the Garden of Eden, (2014) S.Calhoun, symmetry experiment
Without contraries is no progres-
sion. Attraction and repulsion, rea-
son and energy, love and hate, are
necessary to human existence.
From these contraries spring what
the religious call Good and Evil.
Good is the passive that obeys reason;
Evil is the active springing from
Good is heaven. Evil is hell.
Energy is Eternal Delight.
Those who restrain desire, do so
because theirs is weak enough to be
restrained; and the restrainer or
reason usurps its place and governs
And being restrained, it by degrees
becomes passive, till it is only the
shadow of desire.
The history of this is written in
Paradise Lost, and the Governor or
Reason is called Messiah.
And the original Archangel or pos-
sessor of the command of the heavenly
host is called the Devil, or Satan, and
his children are called Sin and Death.
But in the book of Job, Milton’s
Messiah is called Satan.
For this history has been adopted by
It indeed appeared to Reason as if
desire was cast out, but the Devil’s
account is, that the Messiah fell, and
formed a heaven of what he stole from
This is shown in the Gospel, where
he prays to the Father to send the
Comforter or desire that Reason may
have ideas to build on, the Jehovah
of the Bible being no other than he
who dwells in flaming fire. Know
that after Christ’s death he became
But in Milton, the Father is Destiny,
the Son a ratio of the five senses, and
the Holy Ghost vacuum !
Note. — The reason Milton wrote
in fetters when he wrote of Angels
and God, and at Uberty when of
Devils and Hell, is because he was
a true poet, and of the Devil’s party
without knowing it.
excerpts from William Blake – The Marriage of Heaven and Hell (fulltext)
In zoom mode in Photoshop, while preparing a large new piece to be reduced to a PNG for publishing on the gallery blog, an interesting overall configuration of small details in the edge style of the digital image file.
Because I’m nowadays very sensitive to the level of complexity a possibly worthwhile mirror transformation requires to hopefully capture an intriguing symmetry, I moved around the small scale details looking for a candidate. The first image shows the workflow and the second image above is the detail I discovered.
The result is a symmetry I like. (more I like)
The actual details of the 300dpi original are too small to really see in the 16×10″ proof.
The two hallmarks of my creative ethos and artistic experimentation are: generativity and recursion. I work toward a surprising conclusion by implicating those two procedural factors. In the visual realm the manifestation of both is very clearly exemplified in the above example: the discovery of a small scale within the large scale provides a recursive capture and the mirroring manipulation generates the symmetry. I act as a spotter.
Interestingly, the small scale details result from generative manipulations of the original piece, and the original piece itself is the result of blending two layers both captured in different generative procedures that are keyed by programmed search routines. Those generative instrumentalities, then, represent a recursive routine in their own right.
The final recursion is: this all evokes Gregory Bateson. (see: Peter Harries-Jones: Gregory Bateson, Heterarchies, and the Topology of Recursion. Cybernetics and Human Knowing 12(1-2): 168-174 (2005))
Among Bateson scholars, Peter Harries-Jones (1995) is notable for looking at Gregory’s “ecology of mind” in the context of his mature work, using terms for it associated with that period, “recursive epistemology” or “ecological epistemology.” The processes with which Gregory was concerned were essentially processes of knowing: perception, communication, coding and translation. Ergo epistemology. But basic to this epistemology was the differentiation of logical levels, including the relationship between the knower and the known, ergo a recursive epistemology. Ideally, the relationship between the patterns of the biological world and our understanding of it would be one of congruence, of fit, a broader and more pervasive similarity than the ability to predict in experimental contexts that depend upon simplification and selective attention. It seems useful to refer to Gregory’s ecology of mind as an epistemological ecology to contrast it with the largely materialistic ecology of academic departments. It seems essential to underline that recursiveness is a necessary feature of such an epistemology (and perhaps of every epistemology, since every effort to know about knowing involves the cat trying to swallow its own tail).
Bateson was haunted in his last years by a sense of urgency, a sense that the narrow definition of human purposes, reinforced by technology, would lead to irreversible disasters, and that only a better epistemology could save us. Certainly irreversibilities lie all around us, many, like global warming, the decay of the ozone layer, and the movement of poisons through global food chains, set on courses it is too late to change although we have yet to suffer their full effect. Still, the situation has not worsened as rapidly as he predicted and perhaps he sometimes succumbed to the lure of dramatizing a message in order to get it across in ways that later undermine that message. But the habits of mind that he described can be seen in every newspaper or newscast: the search for short term solutions that worsen the problem over time (often by mirroring it, such as violence used to oppose violence); the focus on individual persons or organisms or even species, seen in isolation; the tendency to let technological possibility or economic indicators replace reflection; the effort to maximize single variables (like profit) rather than optimizing the relationship among a complex set of variables.
Mary Catherine Bateson – new Introduction to Step to An Ecology of Mind by Gregory Bateson, 2000)
One last recursive piece – that can be thought of as recursive in a second order, thus by way of duplication and “re-relation.”
Amusement Park – S.Calhoun 2014 – 14×11″ – from a photograph
Of course there’s a giant genre of youtube videos featuring point-of-view roller coaster rides. For me, nearing sixty, the scariest thing about a roller coaster is waiting in line for a couple of hours.
Camus’s would-be favorite:
There once lived a great warrior. Though quite old, he still was able to defeat any challenger. His reputation extended far and wide throughout the land and many students gathered to study under him.
One day an infamous young warrior arrived at the village. He was determined to be the first man to defeat the great master. Along with his strength, he had an uncanny ability to spot and exploit any weakness in an opponent. He would wait for his opponent to make the first move, thus revealing a weakness, and then would strike with merciless force and lightning speed. No one had ever lasted with him in a match beyond the first move.
Much against the advice of his concerned students, the old master gladly accepted the young warrior’s challenge. As the two squared off for battle, the young warrior began to hurl insults at the old master. He threw dirt and spit in his face. For hours he verbally assaulted him with every curse and insult known to mankind. But the old warrior merely stood there motionless and calm. Finally, the young warrior exhausted himself. Knowing he was defeated, he left feeling shamed.
Somewhat disappointed that he did not fight the insolent youth, the students gathered around the old master and questioned him. “How could you endure such an indignity? How did you drive him away?”
“If someone comes to give you a gift and you do not receive it,” the master replied, “to whom does the gift belong?”
from: Zen Stories to Tell Your Neighbors
The first example is the final version. Second is the original photograph of lilies taken in our backyard, and then follow several versions. Recently, I’ve taken my one year+ experiments in applying symmetry translations to photographs and other sources in a new direction by applying additional generative content to the pre-mirrored raw sources. If that content is itself a symmetry, then I can mirror the symmetry in the mirroring of the conjoined source.
The final version reflects–pun intended–the layering of a pattern over the photo of the lilies. This pattern was derived on the iPad using an app, then mirrored, enlarged, layered at partial opacity over the photograph and mirrored a last time.
symmetry experiments: tumblr
my naive art: online ongoing gallery
On July 2 I publicized the new Tumblr site for barely washed results from the symmetry section of the visual lab.
Soon enough I realized the title of the Tumblr blog and the URL were not in alignment. I cast off the old URL and sent all the old addresses into something like intertube purgatory. However, the now congruent site at least reflects its theme in its titling and addressing.